Witness Statement, Laura and Ryanne


Witness Statement for the Humane Putting Down of a Suffering Senior Horse

Date: Saturday, July 6, 2024

Location: 531 Hwy 35, Pontypool, Ontario, L0A1K0

Details of the Event:

This statement is provided to clarify the facts surrounding the burial of Maizy, a senior horse suffering from severe heaves, as assessed by Port Perry Veterinary Services. The veterinarian determined that Maizy's condition was incurable and that euthanasia was the most humane option. The decision to proceed with euthanasia was made by Maizy's owner, Lindsey Partridge, in consultation with James and Frank Partridge, who carried out the procedure legally. The Veterinary statement showing Maizy's examination consult is below which took place on July 5, 2024. 

Witnesses:

  • Laura Goble
  • Ryanne Reed

 

Statement of Observed Facts:

This statement is provided to verify the following facts regarding the euthanasia and burial of a senior horse, Maizy, conducted on July 6, 2024, at the above location.

1. Arrival and Initial Observations

  • Laura Goble and Ryanne Reed arrived at approximately 7:30 AM to care for their own horses (arrived in their own vehicles, separately, at approximately the same time).
  • At the time of their arrival, the tractor had not yet been started or driven down the hill where the burial process was planned.
  • James and Frank Partridge were already at the designated burial site down the hill, preparing for the burial, while the tractor and additional tools remained back at the barn.
  • Lindsey informed Laura and Ryanne that Maizy had already been laid to rest before their arrival, and explained the burial would take place at the work from James and Frank Partridge. Lindsey explained some details as to why they opted to put down Maizy that morning which included that the vet had determined the day previously that Maizy was suffering and there was no treatment or cure for her. 

2. Horses Secured Away from Burial Site

  • All horses on the property were observed to be secured behind round pen panels at the top of the hill, ensuring they could not access the burial site (located 100+ft away) and the horses were unlikely to view as the panels were set back from the hill, and pick up trucks with a tarp were use to block the view of the burial area. The panels also ensured that clients retrieving horses from the pasture were not exposed to the burial area.
  • It is confirmed that these panels remained in place until the burial process was fully completed. The entire grass section of paddock that the burial site was located in remained with the gate closed so horses did not have access. Horses were kept out of the fenced-off area for several weeks afterward to allow the ground to settle before being reopened for grazing. 

3. Interaction with Another Client

  • Earlier that morning, prior to the burial process starting, a client began walking down the hill to retrieve their horse for a lesson. Lindsey Partridge, who was present with James and Frank Partridge at the time, intercepted the client partway down the hill. Lindsey explained that a horse had been put down earlier, pointed out the panels securing the other horses, and advised the client that the area was temporarily closed off for burial.
  • The client complied and retrieved their horse without issue, respecting the temporary closure of the burial area.
  • Because the pick up trucks were in place with a tarp blocking views, and because the actual burial process had not yet started, the client did not see anything disturbing and did not voice any complaint. 

4. Confirmation of Burial Process

  • James and Frank Partridge were solely responsible for managing the burial process at the site down the hill. No other clients or individuals, including Laura Goble and Ryanne Reed, were involved in or present at the burial location during the process.
  • The days following the burial, the burial site was checked regularly following completion, and the horses were not permitted near the area until the burial was finalized and the ground sufficiently settled.
  • On July 10th after a heavy rain and the coyotes had dug up some parts of the horse, Lindsey acted right away and that same evening another farmer came with their bigger tractor that could dig deeper and remedied the situation. Afterwards there were no more issues with scavengers. The horses remained fenced off from the area during this time. 

Below is general information that Lindsey discussed with Laura and Ryanne as to why the decision to put down and bury the horse in the manner completed were made - this decision was solely made by Lindsey Partridge as the owner of the horse. Laura and Ryanne were not involved with the decision, planning, or implementing of the plan. 

Evidence Supporting the Decision to Use a Gunshot Over Chemical Euthanasia

When euthanizing horses, environmental and ecological risks associated with chemical euthanasia, particularly using sodium pentobarbital, have been documented. Below are key findings and research that support the decision to use a gunshot for euthanasia, along with proper burial practices:

  1. Persistence of Pentobarbital in Carcasses
    Sodium pentobarbital, the drug commonly used for euthanasia, can persist in animal carcasses for extended periods. Research indicates that pentobarbital remains detectable in composted horse remains for up to 367 days, posing risks of groundwater and soil contamination.
    Source: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26020203/

  2. Secondary Poisoning of Scavengers
    Secondary poisoning occurs when scavenging animals consume tissues from chemically euthanized horses. Documented cases include:

  3. Environmental Impact of Burial
    Horses euthanized with chemical agents can cause environmental contamination if not disposed of correctly. Sodium pentobarbital can leach into the ground, contaminating soil and water. Proper burial regulations—such as ensuring sufficient depth and distance from water sources—are critical but can still carry risks.
    Source: https://madbarn.com/horse-euthanasia-and-carcass-disposal/

Advantages of Gunshot Euthanasia

Using a gunshot for euthanasia, when done humanely and precisely, avoids introducing toxic substances like pentobarbital into the environment. This method:

  • Eliminates risks of secondary poisoning to scavengers.
  • Prevents potential soil and groundwater contamination.
  • Offers an environmentally safer option when followed by proper burial practices.

By considering these factors, a gunshot method can be seen as a more sustainable and responsible alternative to chemical euthanasia.

Additional Considerations: Challenges with Deadstock Removal for Euthanized Horses

While the option to euthanize a horse and have it removed by deadstock services for cremation is available, this method presents significant logistical, financial, and reputational challenges for farms, particularly in emergency situations or during busy seasons. Below are specific considerations based on prior experiences:

1. Scheduling and Delays in Deadstock Removal

  • Unpredictable Delays: Deadstock removal services can often be delayed, particularly during high-demand periods. For example, when the horse Moose had to be euthanized in the winter, deadstock removal services were so busy that the carcass remained on the property for a week. While frozen winter conditions mitigated decay, odor, and pests, such delays pose greater risks in warmer months.

Laura Goble is a witness to Moose needing to be put down by a veterinarian, and the carcass remaining at the farm for days until the deadstock removal could come pick up. 

  • Limited Service Hours: Deadstock removal services typically operate during weekday business hours. This scheduling may conflict with the farm’s peak activity times, such as lessons, camps, or events, leading to additional disruptions.

2. Logistical Challenges in Summer

  • Decaying Carcass Risks: In summer, warm temperatures accelerate decomposition, leading to odors, pests (e.g., flies), and increased attraction of predators like coyotes. These factors create health and safety risks for the farm.
  • Visibility to Clients: Due to the layout of the farm, the carcass must be stored in a location accessible for removal, which would be visible to clients, riders, and horses. This could upset clients, particularly during high-traffic times such as summer camps or evening lessons.
  • Unpleasant Removal Process: The process of deadstock removal involves using a winch to load the carcass onto a truck, often alongside other deceased animals. This highly visible and unpleasant process can leave a lasting negative impression on clients, particularly children participating in summer camps.

3. Financial Costs

  • Deadstock removal services and subsequent cremation can be costly, adding financial strain on the facility. These costs are in addition to the already significant expenses of emergency euthanasia and other related services.

4. Environmental and Wildlife Risks

  • If a horse is euthanized with chemical agents like sodium pentobarbital and stored on the property for an extended time, there remains a risk of contamination. Even if the carcass is eventually removed, leaching of pentobarbital into soil or scavenging by wildlife before pickup could result in environmental and ecological harm.

5. Minimizing Disruption During Busy Seasons

  • During summertime, when the farm operates at full capacity with lessons and camps, maintaining a serene and professional environment is crucial. The presence of a carcass or the removal process can negatively affect client satisfaction, disrupt activities, and potentially damage the farm’s reputation.

Conclusion: Why Gunshot Euthanasia and Immediate Burial Was the Best Option

Given these factors, relying on deadstock removal was not a viable solution for the farm. The risks of delays, decay, client upset, and additional costs outweighed the benefits of this method. By choosing gunshot euthanasia and immediate burial, the farm was able to:

  • Avoid the contamination risks of burying a chemically euthanized horse.
  • Prevent upsetting clients with visible carcasses or removal processes.
  • Maintain the farm’s professional atmosphere, especially during its busiest season.
  • Eliminate the logistical and financial burdens associated with deadstock removal services.

This approach prioritized the health, safety, and satisfaction of clients, wildlife, and the farm’s operations while respecting environmental considerations.

Leave this empty:

Signature arrow sign here


Signature Certificate
Document name: Witness Statement, Laura and Ryanne
lock iconUnique Document ID: a53fca81251d09b8bf404701a9467fb4d5268d19
Timestamp Audit
January 23, 2025 3:17 pm ESTWitness Statement, Laura and Ryanne Uploaded by Lindsey Partridge - phhschedule@gmail.com IP 24.137.47.228