Jenn Expert Statement


EXPERT OPINION OF JENNIFER MUSICARO

Name: Jennifer Musicaro

Business: Harmonia Equestrian Centre

Address: 832 Copeland Rd, Suffolk, Virginia 23434

jenniferrosetraining@gmail.com 

I. Professional Background

My name is Jennifer Musicaro. I am a professional horse trainer and owner of Harmonia Equestrian Centre in Suffolk, Virginia.

I have over 25 years of professional experience training horses. I have personally trained or directly worked with more than 800 horses. This includes taming feral horses, starting young horses under saddle, retraining problem horses, and working with horses that many trainers consider too challenging, including former bronc rodeo horses.

As of March 2, 2026, I have adopted and trained 19 mustangs from feral to safe riding horses. My major competition results include:

• Maryland Mustang Extravaganza Champion – 2024

• Maryland Mustang Extravaganza Champion – 2025

• Pennsylvania Devils Garden Mustang Challenge – 2024

• Kentucky Mustang Classic 2025 – Top 10 in Working Equitation

My work is hands-on. I am directly involved from the first halter through the first ride and beyond. I regularly evaluate horse behaviour, safety, and training progress in young and formerly feral horses.

II. Materials Reviewed

I reviewed the following videos:

• Video A – short video clip showing open-hand contacts https://drive.google.com/file/d/1D2wB-9ObJ10zoOgsomRwWq1oj5N3DESy/view?usp=sharing

• Video B – Short clip of the horse being led around the mounting block 

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1hNKO44Zbx9e7qSuSVJfNonopw1njGmwl/view?usp=sharing

• Video C – Full unedited 30+ minute first ride session https://youtu.be/GB-4OQpewKY

Video D: Mustang training incident involving a horse flipping over a feeder

Link: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1c8gsBfZOFXv03iTfl7imMAyWyuKoFD4p/view

 

Some of these materials were publicly circulated and include descriptions attributed to Breanna Godfrey.

My review is limited to training and behavioural interpretation only.

II. General Mustang Training Context

Mustangs start out very flighty. That is normal for a feral horse. They are prey animals, so tight spaces, pressure, or sudden changes can make them unsure.

A mounting block can also feel uncertain because the handler’s height changes. Small things like noise, movement, or changes in position can trigger a reaction, and those things can happen outside the handler’s control.

It is common for young or recently feral mustangs to crowd a person or step into the handler’s space while they are still learning boundaries.

Maintaining personal space is very important for safety. Horses are large animals, and even unintentional movement into a handler can cause injury. Over my career I have seen handlers get knocked over or hurt when a horse crowds them.

For that reason, trainers sometimes need to give a stronger or quicker correction when a horse is not respecting space, especially in close quarters.

IV. Review of Video A 

Video A does not show the full context before or after the interaction. It begins in the middle of the moment and ends right after the horse steps back.

In the clip:

The handler’s hand is open

The contacts land on the side of the horse’s nose and cheek

The handler says “over”

The horse steps slightly backward

The contacts are stronger than what would be used in a calm, routine moment. However, they are open-hand contacts aimed at moving the horse away to create space.

The first two contacts are very quick and close to the horse’s face, as if the handler is trying to quickly create space. The third and fourth contacts show increased reach, which suggests escalation of pressure when the horse does not respond right away.

This is consistent with a situation where the horse is not yielding space and the handler is increasing pressure to regain a safe distance.

There is no closed-fist punch visible.

The clip I reviewed was accompanied by a description attributed to Breanna Godfrey stating that the handler was “punching him in the face multiple times.” That description does not match what is visible in the video.

No whip, flag, chain, or other tools are present. The handler is using only their hand, a loose lead rope, and is wearing a treat pouch.

A horse’s cheek and nose area are structurally strong. An open human hand in this context would not be expected to cause structural injury. I do not see signs of physical harm in the clip.

Video A does not show what happened immediately before the contact. Based on my experience, situations involving crowding or pressure can escalate quickly, and a handler may respond more firmly in that moment to maintain safety.

V. Review of Video B (Mounting Block Work)

Video B shows the horse being led around a mounting block while wearing a bareback pad.

This is a normal early step when starting a horse under saddle.

The positioning of the horse and handler in Video B does not match the start of Video A. Based on what is visible, these do not appear to be one continuous sequence.

The work shown in Video B is consistent with standard and safe training practices for a young or green horse..

VI. Review of Video C (Full Unedited First Ride Session)

Video C is an exceptionally calm and well-executed first ride for a mustang. In my experience, even well-prepared mustangs often show some tension, bucks, or scooting on a first ride. This horse does not display signs of stress, fear, or being overwhelmed.

The horse:

• Stands quietly for mounting

• Eats treats

• Maintains steady breathing

• Flicks ears toward the handler (showing attention, not fear)

• Rests a hind leg (a clear sign of relaxation)

The handler approaches the horse’s face, makes hand gestures, and applies light contact. The horse does not flinch, pull away, or show signs of fear. These behaviours are not consistent with a horse that has been excessively hit in the face or developed fear from the handler. The horse looks calm and accepting of training and handling. 

VII. Review of Video D (Mustang Training Incident)

Video D shows a mustang in an enclosed area during an early-stage training interaction.

In the video:

The handler approaches the horse

The horse faces the handler

The handler continues to advance

The horse attempts to flee

The horse tries to go over a feeder, becomes entangled, and flips over onto its back

This is an example of a horse becoming overwhelmed and reacting through flight behaviour.

In early mustang training, it is common for horses to react quickly when they feel pressure. When overwhelmed, they may make unsafe or unplanned movements, including attempting to jump obstacles or escape confined areas.

This type of reaction is not unusual in early training stages and highlights how quickly a situation can become dangerous for both the horse and the handler.

This video demonstrates why maintaining safe space and responding quickly to a horse’s movement is important. It also shows that handlers may need to act quickly to protect themselves when a horse moves into or toward their space.

VIII. Professional Opinion

Based on my 25+ years of experience training horses, including mustangs, and my review of the materials:

Video A shows open-hand contact used to move the horse out of the handler’s space. It does not show a closed-fist punch.

The clip is very short and begins and ends mid-event, which removes important context.

The description attributed to Breanna Godfrey that the handler was “punching him in the face multiple times” does not match what is visible in the video.

Video B and Video C show normal, safe, and appropriate early training practices.

The horse in Video C shows relaxed and willing behaviour and does not show signs of fear toward the handler.

Video D demonstrates how quickly a mustang can react when feeling pressure, and why maintaining personal space is important for safety.

In my professional opinion, the short clip (Video A) does not, on its own, demonstrate abuse. When considered alongside the full available footage and standard training practices, it is consistent with a handler applying pressure to maintain space and safety.

My opinion is limited to training and behavioural interpretation only.

Jennifer Musicaro

 

 

Leave this empty:

Signature arrow sign here


Signature Certificate
Document name: Jenn Expert Statement
lock iconUnique Document ID: 4e7b7faf6e470c6d55a563f8cffeb6221765bf43
Timestamp Audit
April 28, 2026 12:12 pm ESTJenn Expert Statement Uploaded by Lindsey Partridge - phhschedule@gmail.com IP 24.137.47.228